Debugging IPSec VPN’s.
As promised I mentioned we were going to go over some debug output from 2 Cisco ISRs establishing an IPSec VPN. Now I’m not going to go over every line in the debug but I’ll touch on some of the things to look out for. Now, from the beginning.
From the first line you can see ISAKMP is enabled and it starts looking for it’s peer (172.17.1.1 in this case), the router realizes it needs to use main mode and it locates the PSK for this particular peer, so right off the bat we know the peer we are establish a IPSec VPN with, along with what PSK/Keyring we are going to be using. Next we see some mention of NAT-T and RFC 3947, this is essential so both devices know if there is any NAT”ing done in between the two devices and if so where it is being done. (If you want a bit more information on that I’d say give RFC3947 a glance over, it tells you why this is done) Next you will see the line New State = IKE_I_MM1 meaning the first packet in the IKE Phase I process has been sent out, following by the router so nicely telling us (with line beginning Main Mode exchange). Next you see the ISAKMP state change to MMO_NO_STATE, this is because we have sent out a packet but we have not received a response yet, so we are unable to continue along with the process. Then in the second to last line we see Input = IKE_MESG_FROM_PEER, IKE_MM_EXCH meaning we received a response from the peer (the second packet in the process).
Now that we received the second packet (which contains the remote device ISAKMP polices) this router will compare the remote peers ISAKMP policies to it’s own, you’ll notice right after it says the atts are acceptable, so our policies match! You’ll also see the last 3 lines mention the lifetime: 86400 this is default ISAKMP lifetime in seconds you will want these to match on both sides of the tunnel, it’s not something to be really concerned about when building VPN’s between two Cisco devices but I would pay attention to it when building VPNs between different vendors.
Next we see the ISAKMP state proceed to MM_SA_SETUP which is another confirmation that the ISAKMP policies match and the 2 peers are going to continue along with the process. Also notice the the progressions of Old State = IKE_I_MM2 New State = IKE_I_MM3 and Old State = IKE_I_MM3 New State = IKE_I_MM4 telling us the third and fourth packets have been exchanged, shortly after that you see the router processes the NONCE payload which is used to generate the DH secret.
Now that we have exchanged the first four packets it starts authenticating the peer using the configured method (PSK in this case), and we see this in the line Sending packet to 172.17.1.1 my_port 500 peer_port 500 (i) MM_KEY_EXCH, and the line Old State = IKE_I_MM4 New State = IKE_I_MM5 telling us the fifth packet has been sent. Right after we see that we received the response packet from the peer in line Received packet from 172.17.1.1 dport 500 sport 500 global (i) MM_KEY_EXCH, then after it processes the payload, we see the line SA authentication status: authenticated, telling us the peer successfully authenticated phase I.
The above output just verifies everything we saw and said in the previous output, it shows us we received the sixth packet (Old State = IKE_I_MM5 New State = IKE_I_MM6), and Main Mode has been complete in the following lines. Input =IKE_MESG_INTERNAL, IKE_PROCESS_COMPLETE and Old State = IKE_I_MM6 New State = IKE_P1_COMPLETE.
These next group of lines tell us that phase II quick mode is starting and ISAKMP status is QM_IDLE. Then we see the router sends the first packet in the process and receives the second packet in the quick mode process from the remote device, after that it begins to process the payloads.
Now that we received the second packet from the remote device which contained its IPSec transform-sets the router compares it to its own transform-sets. The router then accepts the transform-set, as long as it matches its own transform-set and, it does. We know this because of the line atts are acceptable and it creates IPSec SAs with the peer (in the line Creating IPSec SAs).
Now, that the IPSec SAs have been established the process is pretty much complete and the IPSec VPN (both phase I and II) is negotiated and formed. There is still some more output displayed. The first 10 of so lines tell us the SPI’s associated with these IPSec peers and the IPSec security association lifetimes, like ISAKMP lifetimes you will want the IPSec lifetimes to match as well. Now there are another dozen of so lines left but the key line in middle of that Old State = IKE_QM_R_QM2 New State = IKE_QM_PHASE2_COMPLETE is the one that tells Phase II quick mode is complete and was successful. As if forming IPSec SAs were not enough.
So there we have the typical debug output of an IPSec VPN, assuming everything is configured properly on both ends, now hopefully after going this and my post from a few weeks ago going over IKE in general you’ll have a deeper understanding of what really goes on when a routers try to form an IPSec VPN.